Zapproved
  • Products
    • ZDiscovery Suite
      • Legal Hold Pro
      • Digital Discovery Pro
    • Pricing
    • Security
    • Request a Demo
  • Solutions
    • Legal Hold Software Solutions For Legal Teams
    • Office 365 Preservations
    • Processing & Culling
    • Early Case Assessment
    • Review and Production
    • Internal Investigations
    • Information Requests
  • Resources
    • Resources
    • Blog
    • Events
    • Webinars
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • Partners
    • Recognition
    • News Releases
    • Careers
    • Community Engagement
    • Contact Us
  • Login
  • See a Demo
Select Page

Puerto Rico Magistrate Judge Denies Adverse Inference Motion Absent of Prejudice for Spoliation of Executives’ Personal Email

by Zapproved | Dec 1, 2013 | Case Law, Ediscovery, Resources

The plaintiff in a commercial litigation between two telecom providers in Puerto Rico brought a motion for an adverse inference sanction when it learned that relevant personal emails of the defendant’s executives were not preserved. The court denied the motion citing the defendants’ preservation efforts including a timely litigation hold, willingness to recover lost emails, and that the plaintiff “cannot articulate a clear theory of how it has suffered prejudice….” (*2)

The case of Puerto Rico Tel. Co., Inc. v. San Juan Cable, LLC, No. 11-2135 (GAG/BJM), 2013 WL 5533711 (D.P.R. Oct. 7, 2013) is a good example that highlights a common blind spot in the preservation process. San Juan Cable, upon becoming aware of the litigation, issued a litigation hold to employees within a month. This hold notice was also sent to the company’s officers. A year later, those officers left the company just about when discovery was getting underway resulting in the loss of business-related emails that were sent and received on their personal email accounts.

Despite instructions to employees to preserve any relevant evidence, including electronic data, San Juan Cable “failed to preserve relevant emails within its control…. [The defendant] presumably knew its managing officers used their personal email accounts to engage in company business, and thus its duty to preserve extended to those personal email accounts.” The court found no evidence of intentional deletion and that “only three email chains were in fact ‘lost’” while three others were “recovered through other sources.” (*2)

In weighing the motion, the court concluded that, “Any prejudice suffered by [the plaintiff] is currently speculative; [they have] not proffered evidence that tends to show the allegedly ‘lost’ emails would actually support [their] claims or weaken [the defendants’] defenses. Therefore, under the circumstances before me, there is insufficient foundation for an adverse inference instruction.”

Puerto Rico Tel. Co. v. San Juan Cable shows us that the duty to preserve extends beyond the corporate systems and into personal accounts if employees conducted business there. Failure to keep them was “a breach of its duty to preserve and constitutes spoliation.” (*1) While issuing a litigation hold in a timely manner was correct, this spoliation resulted from a failure to communicate clearly that that hold extended to personal accounts, the failure to follow-up, and not having a process in place for departing employees.

On the positive side, San Juan Cable did cooperate once the spoliation was discovered and worked to find alternative sources of the lost ESI. These remedial actions, including documentation of the legal hold, were sufficient to demonstrate that they were not destroying evidence in bad faith and the inability to show prejudice on the plaintiff’s part were the keys to avoiding a harsh sanction of an adverse inference instruction.

Further Reading:

  • Electronic Discovery Law Blog, LLP, No Sanctions for Spoliation of Emails in Former Officers’ Personal Accounts Absent Evidence of Bad Faith or Prejudice, K&L Gates, LLP, October 31, 2013.
  • Gilliland, Joshua, Control of Personal Email Accounts & Litigation Holds, Bow Tie Law Blog, October 10, 2013.

Personal email accountspreservation

Related Content

No reasonable anticipation of litigation given longstanding relationship and lack of communication about incident

No reasonable anticipation of litigation given longstanding relationship and lack of communication about incident

by Caitlin Lilly | Oct 17, 2019 | Case Law

In this breach of contract case, the court denied the plaintiffs’ motion for sanctions, finding that the defendants were under no duty to preserve evidence at the time of its loss.

Stormy seas, waves, clouds, wind as seen through a cruise ship porthole.

Preserved 91-minute video sufficient to capture ‘horrific storm’

by Zapproved | Oct 3, 2019 | Case Law

In this claim for injuries sustained during a boat cruise, the court began its opinion by noting that “a picture is worth a thousand words.” Given that, “surely a video must be worth significantly more” — and video evidence from 200 surveillance cameras worth yet more than that.

Silhouetted image of three defendants who deleted evidence before and after legal hold, then misrepresented its availability, resulting in spoliation sanctions.

Defendants deleted evidence before and after legal hold, then misrepresented its availability

by Zapproved | Sep 23, 2019 | Case Law

In this employment case, the magistrate imposed monetary sanctions and recommended an adverse inference jury instruction for the defendants’ spoliation of electronically stored information (ESI). Although the defendants were on notice of the plaintiff’s claims and had a clear obligation to preserve relevant information, they intentionally deleted her email and work data...

Zapproved logo

Founded in 2008, Zapproved builds easy-to-use litigation response software designed to help corporate legal teams drive down costs, reduce risk, and build a better process. With our unwavering commitment to keeping our 350+ corporate customers ridiculously successful, we are proud to have earned a 99% retention rate.

  • Products
  • ZDiscovery
  • Legal Hold Pro
  • Digital Discovery Pro
  • Security
  • Company
  • COVID-19
  • About Us
  • Careers
  • Press
  • Ediscovery Resources
  • Blog
  • Connect
  • Contact Us
  • Login
  • See a Demo
  • PREX
  • Webinars

    • Facebook

    • Twitter

    • LinkedIn
© 2021 Zapproved LLC. All rights reserved.
|
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy